WE ARE FORUM BANTER!!!
Talk about the things that matter to you!!
Howdy stranger!! It looks like you're new here.
If you want to get involved, click on the button below!
Join The Conversation

Movie Talk Critically Panned Movies But Loved By Many

Gemma

Gemma

Staff member Staff member Staff member Staff member Staff member
Threads
85
Messages
471
Reaction score
223
For me, the Fifty Shades of Grey films come readily to mind. They are considered trash by the critics and deserve their reputation but yet find an audience and are genuinely popular. I'm not a fan of these 3 films and they are among the worst films but are popular with many.

Here's some more examples (from Rotten Tomatoes)

bright.jpg equilibrium.jpg fearAndLoathing.jpg

What movies come to mind as critically panned (and generally deserving to be!) but yet are loved by many?
 
SteveO

SteveO

Staff member Staff member
Threads
17
Messages
672
Reaction score
107
The Rocky Horror Picture Show was panned on release but saved by an obsessive audience and subsequently reappraised.

Scarface similarly bombed with the critics, did moderately successful box office and became a VHS and DVD bestseller before being retrospectively viewed far more positively by critics.
 
THREAD STARTER
Gemma

Gemma

Staff member Staff member Staff member Staff member Staff member
Threads
85
Messages
471
Reaction score
223
Law Abiding Citizen is another one that was panned by the critics yet the audience really like it.

I didn't mind it myself. Like most Gerard Butler movies, if you switch your brain off before watching you'll be just fine.
 
Dylan

Dylan

Staff member Staff member
Threads
10
Messages
224
Reaction score
41
Not sure if it was panned universally by critics, or just on Rotten Tomatoes, but Event Horizon got something like a 26% rating from critics.
 
SteveO

SteveO

Staff member Staff member
Threads
17
Messages
672
Reaction score
107
Labyrinth (with David Bowie and Jennifer Connolly) did badly on release, but has a massive following now. Never got that major DVD/ Blu-Ray release it kind of deserves.
 
Connie

Connie

Staff member
Threads
10
Messages
97
Reaction score
27
Con Air is one that springs to mind. So terrible, yet so brilliant. For John Malkovich and Steve Buscemi's part alone.
 
THREAD STARTER
Gemma

Gemma

Staff member Staff member Staff member Staff member Staff member
Threads
85
Messages
471
Reaction score
223
Grease was panned by the critics too, but they knew it would be a hit.
 
SteveO

SteveO

Staff member Staff member
Threads
17
Messages
672
Reaction score
107
Hudson Hawk. Huge flop, Box Office disaster, panned by critics. Strangely good.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Latest Community Activity

  • Gemma
    Gemma reacted to Janey's recipe Slow Cooker Vegan Bean Chilli with Like Like.
    8 spring onions, trimmed and thinly sliced 450g/1lb sweet potato, peeled and cut into roughly 2cm/¾in chunks 1 yellow pepper, seeds...
  • Gemma
    Gemma replied to the thread Game of Thrones theme song.
    Pretty epic.
  • Gemma
    Gemma replied to the thread Pavarotti (2019).
    Excellent, will need to look out for it :)
  • Gemma
    Gemma reacted to Sazzy's post in the thread Pavarotti (2019) with Love Love.
    Looking forward to this. Such a beautiful voice. @Gemma, one for you lovely xXx
  • Gemma
    Gemma reacted to Geezer's post in the thread Game of Thrones theme song with Like Like.
    Get into the mood for the series finale with this awesome rendition of the Game of Thrones theme song
  • Major Tom
    Major Tom replied to the thread The Latest Boxing Crack.
    Tyson Fury beat Wilder in everyone except the judges eyes without particularly testing his chin. Joshua, and possibly even Whyte, would...
  • Major Tom
    Major Tom replied to the thread Gears of War 5.
    Information on The Coalition’s upcoming Gears 5 has been few and far between, but the developers have nonetheless at least been sharing...
  • Major Tom
    Major Tom reacted to Slenderman's post in the thread Captain Vincent Kompany has left Manchester City with Like Like.
    Great player and leader around the club. His career has been a little blighted by injuries but he oozes class. His goal against...
  • Major Tom
    Major Tom replied to the thread Captain Vincent Kompany has left Manchester City.
    Agreed. One of the best CBs in the Premier League of his generation. Came across as a natural leader and a genuine nice guy. Very...
  • Major Tom
    Major Tom replied to the thread What Games Have You Completed Lately.
    Horizon: Zero Dawn - great, great game, really loved the story, the world and most of the gameplay. My type of gaming experience